Recounting the Lottery
When it was first published (by The New Yorker back in 1948 ), Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” received a lot of attention. The full text is available online, here , where it tops off the site’s list of “Twenty Great American Short Stories.” I read it in an anthology ( Norton Anthology of Short Fiction ). All of this speaks highly of the story’s enduring acclaim. However, I don’t think it’s aged well. (Please read the story before going on, because I’ll spoil the ending, on whose mystery the entire tale is propped up.) “The Lottery” creeps up on you: it starts as a seemingly bucolic celebration in a small town. You see people walking up to a wooden box and drawing slips of paper to see who’ll win the lottery. The person who wins gets stoned to death. It turns out to be a fertility rite. Both the way to pick people and the way to kill them sound very biblical. They are. There’s a strong sense hovering about that adulterers get stoned in the Bible. Well, yes and no. In Chris...